Design patterns for implementing Hive Metastore for Amazon EMR on EKS

In fashionable information architectures, the necessity to handle and question huge datasets effectively, constantly, and precisely is paramount. For organizations that take care of large information processing, managing metadata turns into a important concern. That is the place Hive Metastore (HMS) can function a central metadata retailer, enjoying an important position in these fashionable information architectures.

HMS is a central repository of metadata for Apache Hive tables and different information lake desk codecs (for instance, Apache Iceberg), offering shoppers (akin to Apache Hive, Apache Spark, and Trino) entry to this info utilizing the Metastore Service API. Over time, HMS has turn out to be a foundational part for information lakes, integrating with a various ecosystem of open supply and proprietary instruments.

In non-containerized environments, there was usually just one strategy to implementing HMS—operating it as a service in an Apache Hadoop cluster. With the arrival of containerization in information lakes by applied sciences akin to Docker and Kubernetes, a number of choices for implementing HMS have emerged. These choices supply higher flexibility, permitting organizations to tailor HMS deployment to their particular wants and infrastructure.

On this put up, we are going to discover the structure patterns and exhibit their implementation utilizing Amazon EMR on EKS with Spark Operator job submission kind, guiding you thru the complexities that will help you select one of the best strategy on your use case.

Resolution overview

Previous to Hive 3.0, HMS was tightly built-in with Hive and different Hadoop ecosystem elements. Hive 3.0 launched a Standalone Hive Metastore. This new model of HMS features as an impartial service, decoupled from different Hive and Hadoop elements akin to HiveServer2. This separation permits varied purposes, akin to Apache Spark, to work together immediately with HMS with out requiring a full Hive and Hadoop setting set up. You may be taught extra about different elements of Apache Hive on the Design web page.

On this put up, we are going to use a Standalone Hive Metastore for instance the structure and implementation particulars of assorted design patterns. Any reference to HMS refers to a Standalone Hive Metastore.

The HMS broadly consists of two fundamental elements:

• Backend database: The database is a persistent information retailer that holds all of the metadata, akin to desk schemas, partitions, and information places.
• Metastore service API: The Metastore service API is a stateless service that manages the core performance of the HMS. It handles learn and write operations to the backend database.

Containerization and Kubernetes provides varied structure and implementation choices for HMS, together with, operating:

On this put up, we’ll use Apache Spark as the info processing framework to exhibit these three architectural patterns. Nonetheless, these patterns aren’t restricted to Spark and could be utilized to any information processing framework, akin to Hive or Trino, that depends on HMS for managing metadata and accessing catalog info.

Observe that in a Spark utility, the motive force is chargeable for querying the metastore to fetch desk schemas and places, then distributes this info to the executors. Executors course of the info utilizing the places offered by the motive force, by no means needing to question the metastore immediately. Therefore, within the three patterns described within the following sections, solely the motive force communicates with the HMS, not the executors.

HMS as sidecar container

On this sample, HMS runs as a sidecar container throughout the similar pod as the info processing framework, akin to Apache Spark. This strategy makes use of Kubernetes multi-container pod performance, permitting each HMS and the info processing framework to function collectively in the identical pod. The next determine illustrates this structure, the place the HMS container is a part of Spark driver pod.

This sample is fitted to small-scale deployments the place simplicity is the precedence. As a result of HMS is co-located with the Spark driver, it reduces community overhead and gives an easy setup. Nonetheless, it’s vital to notice that on this strategy HMS operates completely throughout the scope of the mum or dad utility and isn’t accessible by different purposes. Moreover, row conflicts may come up when a number of jobs try to insert information into the identical desk concurrently. To deal with this, you must make it possible for no two jobs are writing to the identical desk concurrently.

Think about this strategy in case you desire a fundamental structure. It’s preferrred for organizations the place a single group manages each the info processing framework (for instance, Apache Spark) and HMS, and there’s no want for different purposes to make use of HMS.

Cluster devoted HMS

On this sample, HMS runs in a number of pods managed by a Kubernetes deployment, usually inside a devoted namespace in the identical information processing EKS cluster. The next determine illustrates this setup, with HMS decoupled from Spark driver pods and different workloads.

This sample works effectively for medium-scale deployments the place reasonable isolation is sufficient, and compute and information wants could be dealt with inside just a few clusters. It gives a stability between useful resource effectivity and isolation, making it preferrred to be used instances the place scaling metadata providers independently is vital, however full decoupling isn’t crucial. Moreover, this sample works effectively when a single group manages each the info processing frameworks and HMS, making certain streamlined operations and alignment with organizational obligations.

By decoupling HMS from Spark driver pods, it could serve a number of shoppers, akin to Apache Spark and Trino, whereas sharing cluster sources. Nonetheless, this strategy may result in useful resource competition in periods of excessive demand, which could be mitigated by imposing tenant isolation on HMS pods.

Exterior HMS

On this structure sample, HMS is deployed in its personal EKS cluster deployed utilizing Kubernetes deployment and uncovered as a Kubernetes Service utilizing AWS Load Balancer Controller, separate from the info processing clusters. The next determine illustrates this setup, the place HMS is configured as an exterior service, separate from the info processing clusters.

This sample fits eventualities the place you desire a centralized metastore service shared throughout a number of information processing clusters. HMS permits totally different information groups to handle their very own information processing clusters whereas counting on the shared metastore for metadata administration. By deploying HMS in a devoted EKS cluster, this sample gives most isolation, impartial scaling, and the pliability to function and managed as its personal impartial service.

Whereas this strategy provides clear separation of issues and the flexibility to scale independently, it additionally introduces larger operational complexity and doubtlessly elevated prices due to the necessity to handle an extra cluster. Think about this sample in case you have strict compliance necessities, want to make sure full isolation for metadata providers, or wish to present a unified metadata catalog service for a number of information groups. It really works effectively in organizations the place totally different groups handle their very own information processing frameworks and depend on a shared metadata retailer for information processing wants. Moreover, the separation permits specialised groups to give attention to their respective areas.

Deploy the answer

Within the the rest of this put up, you’ll discover the implementation particulars for every of the three structure patterns, utilizing EMR on EKS with Spark Operator job submission kind for example to exhibit their implementation. Observe that this implementation hasn’t been examined with different EMR on EKS Spark job submission sorts. You’ll start by deploying the frequent elements that function the inspiration for all of the structure patterns. Subsequent, you’ll deploy the elements particular to every sample. Lastly, you’ll execute Spark jobs to connect with the HMS implementation distinctive to every sample and confirm the profitable execution and retrieval of information and metadata.

To streamline the setup course of, we’ve automated the deployment of frequent infrastructure elements so you possibly can give attention to the important points of every HMS structure. We’ll present detailed info that will help you perceive every step, simplifying the setup whereas preserving the educational expertise.

Situation

To showcase the patterns, you’ll create three clusters:

• Two EMR on EKS clusters: analytics-cluster and datascience-cluster
• An EKS cluster: hivemetastore-cluster

Each analytics-cluster and datascience-cluster function information processing clusters that run Spark workloads, whereas the hivemetastore-cluster hosts the HMS.

You’ll use analytics-cluster for instance the HMS as sidecar and cluster devoted sample. You’ll use all three clusters to exhibit the exterior HMS sample.

Supply code

You could find the codebase within the AWS Samples GitHub repository.

Stipulations

Earlier than you deploy this answer, make it possible for the next conditions are in place:

Arrange frequent infrastructure

Start by establishing the infrastructure elements which can be frequent to all three architectures.

1. Clone the repository to your native machine and set the 2 setting variables. Change with the AWS Area the place you wish to deploy these sources.

git clone https://github.com/aws-samples/sample-emr-eks-hive-metastore-patterns.git
cd sample-emr-eks-hive-metastore-patterns
export REPO_DIR=$(pwd)
export AWS_REGION=

2. Execute the next script to create the shared infrastructure.

cd ${REPO_DIR}/setup
./setup.sh

3. To confirm profitable infrastructure deployment, navigate to the AWS Administration Console for AWS CloudFormation, choose your stack, and verify the Occasions, Sources, and Outputs tabs for completion standing, particulars, and listing of sources created.

You’ve accomplished the setup of the frequent elements that function the inspiration for all architectures. You’ll now deploy the elements particular to every structure and execute Apache Spark jobs to validate the profitable implementation.

HMS in a sidecar container

To implement HMS utilizing the sidecar container sample, the Spark utility requires setting each sidecar and catalog properties within the job configuration file.

1. Execute the next script to configure the analytics-cluster for sidecar sample. For this put up, we saved the HMS database credentials right into a Kubernetes Secret object. We suggest utilizing Kubernetes Exterior Secrets and techniques Operator to fetch HMS database credentials from AWS Secrets and techniques Supervisor.

cd ${REPO_DIR}/hms-sidecar
./configure-hms-sidecar.sh analytics-cluster

2. Assessment the Spark job manifest file spark-hms-sidecar-job.yaml. This file was created by substituting variables within the spark-hms-sidecar-job.tpl template within the earlier step. The next samples spotlight key sections of the manifest file.

spec:
  driver:
  ...
    sidecars:
      # Hive Metastore Sidecar container
      - identify: hive-metastore
        picture: ${AWS_ACCOUNT_ID}.dkr.ecr.${AWS_REGION}.amazonaws.com/hive-metastore:newest
        env:
          # These settings configure metastore to make use of Amazon Postgres RDS as backend database, connecting to it by way of jdbc URL.
          - identify: HIVE_METASTORE_DB_TYPE
            worth: postgres
          - identify: HIVE_METASTORE_DB_DRIVER
            worth: org.postgresql.Driver
          - identify: HIVE_METASTORE_DB_URL
            worth: jdbc:postgresql://${HMS_RDS_PROXY_ENDPOINT}:5432/hivemetastore
          # The warehouse location is specified as an S3 bucket
          - identify: HIVE_METASTORE_WAREHOUSE_LOC
            worth: s3a://${S3_BUCKET_NAME}/warehouse
          - identify: AWS_REGION
            worth: ${AWS_REGION}
          # The database username and password are handed by way of setting variables. The password is retrieved from a Kubernetes secret
          - identify: HIVE_METASTORE_DB_USER
            worth: hive_metastore_user
          - identify: HIVE_METASTORE_DB_PASSWORD
            valueFrom:
              secretKeyRef:
                identify: hms-rds-password
                key: HIVE_METASTORE_DB_PASSWORD

Spark job configuration

spec:  
  sparkConf:
    # Hive Catalog properties
    # Units spark to make use of Hive because the catalog for SQL operations
    spark.sql.catalogImplementation: "hive"
    # HMS is uncovered on localhost:8080 for the reason that sidecar runs in the identical pod. Spark connects to the sidecar by way of this URI
    spark.hadoop.hive.metastore.uris: "thrift://localhost:9083"
    # The information location is ready to S3 bucket
    spark.sql.warehouse.dir: "s3a://${S3_BUCKET_NAME}/warehouse"
    # Retrieve momentary AWS credentials by assuming a task utilizing an internet id token
    spark.hadoop.fs.s3a.aws.credentials.supplier: "com.amazonaws.auth.WebIdentityTokenCredentialsProvider"
    # Configure Spark to make use of S3A filesystem
    spark.hadoop.fs.s3a.impl: "org.apache.hadoop.fs.s3a.S3AFileSystem"

Submit the Spark job and confirm the HMS as sidecar container setup

On this sample, you’ll submit Spark jobs in analytics-cluster. The Spark jobs will connect with the HMS service operating as a sidecar container within the driver pod.

1. Run the Spark job to confirm that the setup was profitable.

kubectl apply -f spark-hms-sidecar-job.yaml

2. Describe the sparkapplication object.

kubectl get sparkapplication -n emr
kubectl describe sparkapplication spark-hms-sidecar-job --namespace emr

3. Listing the pods and observe the variety of containers hooked up to the motive force pod. Wait till the Standing modifications from ContainerCreating to Operating (ought to take only a few seconds).

4. View the motive force logs to validate the output.

kubectl logs spark-hms-sidecar-job-driver --namespace emr

5. When you encounter the next error, anticipate a couple of minutes and rerun the earlier command.

Error from server (BadRequest): container "spark-kubernetes-driver" in pod "spark-hms-sidecar-driver" is ready to begin: ContainerCreating

6. After profitable completion of the job, you see the next message within the logs. The tabular output efficiently validates the setup of HMS as a sidecar container.

...
24/09/17 21:44:00 INFO metastore: Attempting to connect with metastore with URI thrift://localhost:9083
24/09/17 21:44:00 INFO metastore: Opened a connection to metastore, present connections: 1
24/09/17 21:44:00 INFO metastore: Related to metastore.
...
...
+-------+---+-------+---+
|sample|id |identify   |age|
+-------+---+-------+---+
|Sidecar|1 |Alice   |30 |
|Sidecar|2 |Bob     |25 |
|Sidecar|3 |Charlie |35 |
+-------+---+-------+---+

Cluster devoted HMS

To implement HMS utilizing a cluster devoted HMS sample, the Spark utility requires establishing HMS URI and catalog properties within the job configuration file.

1. Execute the next script to configure the analytics-cluster for cluster devoted sample.

cd ${REPO_DIR}/hms-cluster-dedicated
./configure-hms-cluster-dedicated.sh analytics-cluster

2. Confirm the HMS deployment by itemizing the pods and viewing the logs. No Java exceptions within the logs confirms that the Hive Metastore service is operating efficiently.

kubectl get pods --namespace hive-metastore
kubectl logs  --namespace hive-metastore

3. Assessment the Spark job manifest file, spark-hms-cluster-dedicated-job.yaml. This file is created by substituting variables within the spark-hms-cluster-dedicated-job.tpl template within the earlier step. The next pattern highlights key sections of the manifest file.

spec: 
  sparkConf:
    # Hive Catalog properties
    # Units spark to make use of Hive because the catalog for SQL operations
    spark.sql.catalogImplementation: "hive"
    # HMS is operating in a pod and we will connect with it in the identical EKS cluster by way of this URI
    spark.hadoop.hive.metastore.uris: "thrift://hive-metastore-svc.hive-metastore.svc.cluster.native:9083"
    # The information location is ready to S3 bucket
    spark.sql.warehouse.dir: "s3a://${S3_BUCKET_NAME}/warehouse"
    # Retrieve momentary AWS credentials by assuming a task utilizing an internet id token
    spark.hadoop.fs.s3a.aws.credentials.supplier: "com.amazonaws.auth.WebIdentityTokenCredentialsProvider"
    # Configure Spark to make use of S3A filesystem
    spark.hadoop.fs.s3a.impl: "org.apache.hadoop.fs.s3a.S3AFileSystem"

Submit the Spark job and confirm the cluster devoted HMS setup

On this sample, you’ll submit Spark jobs in analytics-cluster. The Spark jobs will connect with the HMS service in the identical information processing EKS cluster.

1. Submit the job.

kubectl apply -f spark-hms-cluster-dedicated-job.yaml -n emr

2. Confirm the standing.

kubectl get sparkapplication -n emr
kubectl describe sparkapplication spark-hms-cluster-dedicated-job --namespace emr

3. Describe driver pod and observe the variety of containers hooked up to the motive force pod. Wait till the standing modifications from ContainerCreating to Operating (ought to take only a few seconds).

4. View the motive force logs to validate the output.

kubectl logs spark-hms-cluster-dedicated-job-driver --namespace emr

5. After profitable completion of the job, you must see the next message within the logs. The tabular output efficiently validates the setup of cluster devoted HMS.

...
24/09/17 21:44:00 INFO metastore: Attempting to connect with metastore with URI thrift://hive-metastore-svc.hive-metastore.svc.cluster.native:9083
24/09/17 21:44:00 INFO metastore: Opened a connection to metastore, present connections: 1
24/09/17 21:44:00 INFO metastore: Related to metastore.
...
...
+-----------------+---+-------+---+
|sample          |id |identify   |age|
+-----------------+---+-------+---+
|Cluster Devoted|1  |Alice  |30 |
|Cluster Devoted|2  |Bob    |25 |
|Cluster Devoted|3  |Charlie|35 |
+-----------------+---+-------+---+

Exterior HMS

To implement an exterior HMS sample, the Spark utility requires establishing an HMS URI for the service endpoint uncovered by hivemetastore-cluster.

1. Execute the next script to configure hivemetastore-cluster for Exterior HMS sample.

cd ${REPO_DIR}/hms-external
./configure-hms-external.sh

2. Assessment the Spark job manifest file spark-hms-external-job.yaml. This file is created by substituting variables within the spark-hms-external-job.tpl template through the setup course of. The next pattern highlights key sections of the manifest file.

spec:
  sparkConf:
    # Hive Catalog properties
    # Units spark to make use of Hive because the catalog for SQL operations
    spark.sql.catalogImplementation: "hive"
    # HMS is operating in a cluster and we will connect with it within the EKS cluster by way of this URI
    spark.hadoop.hive.metastore.uris: "thrift://${HMS_URI_ENDPOINT}:9083"
    # The information location is ready to S3 bucket
    spark.sql.warehouse.dir: "s3a://${S3_BUCKET_NAME}/warehouse"
    # Retrieve momentary AWS credentials by assuming a task utilizing an internet id token
    spark.hadoop.fs.s3a.aws.credentials.supplier: "com.amazonaws.auth.WebIdentityTokenCredentialsProvider"
    # Configure Spark to make use of S3A filesystem
    spark.hadoop.fs.s3a.impl: "org.apache.hadoop.fs.s3a.S3AFileSystem"

Submit the Spark job and confirm the HMS in a separate EKS cluster setup

To confirm the setup, submit Spark jobs in analytics-cluster and datascience-cluster. The Spark jobs will connect with the HMS service within the hivemetastore-cluster.

Use the next steps for analytics-cluster after which for datascience-cluster to confirm that each clusters can connect with the HMS on hivemetastore-cluster.

1. Run the spark job to check the profitable setup. Change with Kubernetes context for analytics-cluster after which for datascience-cluster.

kubectl config use-context 
kubectl apply -f spark-hms-external-job.yaml -n emr

2. Describe the sparkapplication object.

kubectl get sparkapplication spark-hms-external-job -n emr
kubectl describe sparkapplication spark-hms-external-job --namespace emr

3. Listing the pods and observe the variety of containers hooked up to the motive force pod. Wait till the standing modifications from ContainerCreating to Operating (ought to take only a few seconds).

5. View the motive force logs to validate the output on the info processing cluster.

kubectl logs spark-hms-external-job-driver --namespace emr

6. The output ought to seem like the next. The tabular output efficiently validates the setup of HMS in a separate EKS cluster.

After profitable completion of the job, you must have the ability to see the beneath message within the logs.
...
24/09/17 21:44:00 INFO metastore: Attempting to connect with metastore with URI  thrift://k8s-hivemeta-hmsexter-xxxxxx.elb.us-east-1.amazonaws.com:9083
24/09/17 21:44:00 INFO metastore: Opened a connection to metastore, present connections: 1
24/09/17 21:44:00 INFO metastore: Related to metastore.
...
...
+--------+---+-------+---+
|sample |id |identify   |age|
+--------+---+-------+---+
|Exterior|1  |Alice  |30 |
|Exterior|2  |Bob    |25 |
|Exterior|3  |Charlie|35 |
+--------+---+-------+---+

Clear up

To keep away from incurring future fees from the sources created on this tutorial, clear up your setting after you’ve accomplished the steps. You are able to do this by operating the cleanup.sh script, which can safely take away all of the sources provisioned through the setup.

cd ${REPO_DIR}/setup
./cleanup.sh

Conclusion

On this put up, we’ve explored the design patterns for implementing the Hive Metastore (HMS) with EMR on EKS with Spark Operator, every providing distinct benefits relying in your necessities. Whether or not you select to deploy HMS as a sidecar container throughout the Apache Spark Driver pod, or as a Kubernetes deployment within the information processing EKS cluster, or as an exterior HMS service in a separate EKS cluster, the important thing issues revolve round communication effectivity, scalability, useful resource isolation, excessive availability, and safety.

We encourage you to experiment with these patterns in your personal setups, adapting them to suit your distinctive workloads and operational wants. By understanding and making use of these design patterns, you possibly can optimize your Hive Metastore deployments for efficiency, scalability, and safety in your EMR on EKS environments. Discover additional by deploying the answer in your AWS account and share your experiences and insights with the neighborhood.

Concerning the Authors

Avinash Desireddy is a Cloud Infrastructure Architect at AWS, keen about constructing safe purposes and information platforms. He has in depth expertise in Kubernetes, DevOps, and enterprise structure, serving to clients containerize purposes, streamline deployments, and optimize cloud-native environments.

Suvojit Dasgupta is a Principal Knowledge Architect at AWS. He leads a group of expert engineers in designing and constructing scalable information options for AWS clients. He makes a speciality of creating and implementing progressive information architectures to handle advanced enterprise challenges.